Subscriber Discussion Forum:
FabTime Newsletter, Volume 27, No 4

Discussion about setup time tradeoffs, queue time limits, and identifying qualification bottlenecks.

FabTime_Header_Sample_HomePage_SmallerCharts.jpg

Framing the tradeoff re: setup time and tool qualification

A new subscriber asked a question in response to Issue 27.02: Setup Time, Tool Qualification and Cycle Time. He said: “Your point about redundancy adding setup burden gave me something to think about in PCB manufacturing. When assessing a second qualified tool, do you usually start with bottleneck utilization or the extra setup load? How do you frame that trade-off?”

Response from Jennifer: That’s an interesting question. Just to clarify, I think it's that cross-qualification can add a setup burden compared to full dedication. If you have two dedicated tools, each running one recipe, you have no setup time. But if you cross-qualify both tools and need setups when you switch between the two recipes, then you will have some setup time incurred. The utilization of the tools will be higher, but the cycle time per visit will likely be lower (unless the additional setup time takes the tools into an unhealthy utilization range). You can still minimize the setup time by having a setup avoidance policy. (e.g., If there's a lot with a matching setup ID, pick that first. Only do the setup if there are no matching lots.) Where setups are exceptionally long, you probably want to go a step further and only do the setup if lots have been waiting for some longer time. Bottom line: this gets complicated quickly. 

As to how to frame the trade-off, I would start with the current utilization of both tools. It is unlikely in practice that the recipes in question are equal volume. This means that if you cross-qualify and run both recipes on both tools, your pre-setup utilization will be the average of the utilization of the individual tools. You can then make some conservative estimate for how much setup time will be added and add that to the expected loading on the tools to get a revised utilization estimate. Another way to think about this would be to consider how much setup time the tools could absorb before pushing the utilization unacceptably high.

In summary, you frame the trade-off by considering the current utilization of both tools and the future utilization of the shared set of tools. Of course, the tricky part is estimating how much setup time you will need. Historical data for other similar tools might be informative here, but this is a highly complex question in practice. 

INFICON also has a product that can help with tool qualification decisions. Our Tool Qualification Optimizer (TQO) product determines the optimal number of tools to be qualified in a forward-looking time frame, typically two to seven days. This helps to balance UPH and demand per tool automatically. Reach Out to Jennifer for more information.

FabTime Tip: Using AskJen to identify where the effective number of qualified tools (n) is less than planned

Reading the Behnke’s Rule of n paper published recently inspired us to think about how to view and respond to the “effective n” in a fab. We’ve talked in the past about how to use the Tool Qualification WIP Detail chart in FabTime to generate a list of tool qualification-related bottlenecks, defined as operations that have WIP waiting that have a low number of qualified tools. (See software tip #118.) However, this chart only shows which tools are qualified, not which of the qualified tools are currently available to manufacturing. The new AskJen data analysis capability (described in this month’s Community Announcements) makes it easy to extend this analysis to also consider the number of available tools. Here is an example:

First, we asked, using our FabTime demo server:

Example of a query posted to AskJen to generate a list of operations with WIP and one ore fewer qualified tools available.
ToolQualificationBottleneckExampleFig1
Example of a query posted to AskJen to generate a list of operations with WIP and one ore fewer qualified tools available.

Using the Tool Qualification WIP Detail chart, as well as the WIP Hours chart and the Tool WIP and State List chart, AskJen generated a chart showing hours of WIP waiting at operations with less than or equal to one qualified tool available, as shown below. A chart showing the tool state of the relevant tools was also generated but is not shown here.

Chart showing operations with WIP waiting for which 1 or fewer qualified tools are available. Height is hours to process the WIP.
ToolQualificationBottleneckExampleFig2
Chart showing operations with WIP waiting for which 1 or fewer qualified tools are available. Height is hours to process the WIP.

AskJen also presented key findings and recommended next steps:

AskJen presents ranked findings from real-time data analysis.
ToolQualificationBottleneckExampleFig3
AskJen presents ranked findings from real-time data analysis.
AskJen also suggests what to do next to get the fab back on track.
ToolQualificationBottleneckExampleFig4
AskJen also suggests what to do next to get the fab back on track.

FabTime Tip: Generating Queue Limit charts, excluding and including held lots

A new customer asked us recently about generating charts that show lots approaching a queue time limit, both excluding and including lots on hold. Seeing lots that have a queue time limit approaching is, of course, important for reducing the probability of missing the queue time limit and requiring reprocessing. In FabTime, there are two ways to do this.

Method A: Use the Queue Limit Lot List chart to see a list that excludes lots on hold

The Queue Limit Lot List chart is a standard chart in FabTime. This chart displays a list of non-held queued lots, color coded based on a user-specified queue time limit. To use it:

  1. Enter “Queue” in the FabTime search box and select “Queue Limit Lot List” from the Charts section of the results.
  2. Expand the “Lots” section of the filters on the left side of the screen and enter your preferred value in the “QLim:” filter. You can set this value to be a few hours less than the time that triggers reprocessing, to flag the at-risk lots earlier.
  3. Ensure that your entered value is consistent with the units in the “Time” drop-down in the “Age/Cycle Time” section of the filters (minutes, hours, days, or weeks).
  4. Filter for your operation or tool group of interest.
  5. Press the green “Apply Filters” box. An example of the resulting chart is shown below.
Queue Limit Lot List chart in FabTime shows the list of non-held queued lots approaching a time limit.
QueueLimitChartinFabTime
Queue Limit Lot List chart in FabTime shows the list of non-held queued lots approaching a time limit.

Method B: Filter the WIP Lot List chart to include lots on hold

The Queue Limit Lot List chart shown above excludes lots on hold. To generate a similar chart that includes held lots, you can use the regular WIP Lot List chart with appropriate filtering. To do this:

  1. Use the search box to find the “WIP Lot List” chart.
  2. Expand the “Age/Cycle Time” section of the filters and set the “WIP Age >= filter to include lots approaching your desired queue time limit. For example, if the queue time limit is 24 hours, filter to show lots waiting more than 20 hours, so that you’ll see the ones that are approaching the limit. Again, make sure your entered value is consistent with the units selected in the “Time” drop-down.
  3. Now click on the “Formatting” tab below the chart and data table. Use the “Stripe” control to create a red horizontal stripe from just below up to your actual queue time limit value. For example, if the queue time limit is 1.5 days, set the “From” to 1.4 and the “To” to 1.5, and set the “Color” to “Red.” An example of the resulting chart, with the held lots included (the red columns) is shown below.
WIP Lot List chart showing lots approaching queue time limit, held lots included (red columns). Red stripe shows lots approaching queue limit.
WIPLotListwithQueueLimitAddedandHeldLots
WIP Lot List chart showing lots approaching queue time limit, held lots included (red columns). Red stripe shows lots approaching queue limit.

Further Reading

Past issues of the newsletter are available for subscribers to download in PDF format. Existing subscribers can find the archive link in your most recent email newsletter. New subscribers will see the link upon registering. 

We require your consent for video content
More Information